{
  "schema_version": "openlab-answer-neutral-review-request-localized-v1",
  "task_slug": "devos-1954-tungsten-curve20-independent-review",
  "title": "Independent review of de Vos / tungsten / TPRC curve 20",
  "status": "public_static_offline_task",
  "answer_values_included": false,
  "question": "Do the values independently transcribed from TPRC volume 7, table 234, curve 20, and their mapping agree with the pinned EKHI archive record?",
  "source_locator": {
    "tprc_volume": 7,
    "table": 234,
    "curve": 20,
    "material": "tungsten",
    "temperature_k": 2000
  },
  "sources": [
    {
      "label": "tprc_catalog",
      "url": "https://ntrl.ntis.gov/NTRL/dashboard/searchResults/titleDetail/ADA951941.xhtml",
      "allowed_use": "Link and bounded factual comparison; do not redistribute the handbook scan."
    },
    {
      "label": "tprc_public_mirror",
      "url": "https://www.abbottaerospace.com/downloads/ad-a951941-thermophysical-properties-of-matter-the-tprc-data-series-vol-7-thermal-radiative-properties-metallic-elements-and-alloys/",
      "allowed_use": "Lawful independent reading only; do not upload or forward the PDF."
    },
    {
      "label": "ekhi_dataset",
      "url": "https://doi.org/10.6084/m9.figshare.30581240.v2",
      "archive_sha256": "a477aa3b21a79031a72b971c335ea31107690dda1c998aa7739e8a164eb94001",
      "member": "metallic-elements-and-alloys/elements/1954_de-vos_tungsten_normal-spectral-emittance_1.json",
      "member_sha256": "19872fe822f646bf2a223b9366b9d37d4ff051de77fcc4d2d938ade98702b4ff",
      "allowed_use": "Version-pinned, bounded curve comparison only; no database-wide extraction."
    }
  ],
  "sequence": [
    "Do not open KIWERB's de Vos result section before sealing your own source transcription.",
    "Using lawful access, transcribe every wavelength/emittance row shown for the named handbook curve into your own blank worksheet.",
    "Seal that source worksheet by recording its SHA-256, time, page locator, row count and any ambiguous characters.",
    "Run the published offline structural validator on the sealed worksheet; retain its JSON output and verify the validator SHA-256 first.",
    "Only after the seal, open the pinned EKHI archive member and independently compare order, lengths, values and metadata.",
    "Record every agreement and discrepancy without consulting KIWERB's comparison; keep scans and PDFs private.",
    "After completing the return template, run the offline return validator against the sealed worksheet and template; keep its JSON output locally until a human confirms a transfer route."
  ],
  "blank_worksheet_header": "source_row,wavelength_um,emittance,source_page,transcription_note",
  "required_return_fields": [
    "reviewer_role",
    "prior_exposure",
    "method_origin",
    "known_connection",
    "source_worksheet_sha256",
    "sealed_at_utc",
    "source_locator",
    "source_row_count",
    "archive_sha256",
    "member_sha256",
    "comparison_method",
    "agreements",
    "discrepancies",
    "uncertainty",
    "rights_statement"
  ],
  "manual_return": {
    "mailbox": "adrian@vxbes.com",
    "subject_marker": "[KIWERB-DEVOS-RETURN]",
    "route_before_attachment": true,
    "automatic_contact": false
  },
  "boundaries": {
    "live_intake": false,
    "network_submission": false,
    "scan_redistribution": false,
    "independent_validation_claimed": false,
    "finding_claimed": false,
    "payment_promised": false
  },
  "offline_artifacts": {
    "blank_worksheet": {
      "url": "https://kiwerb.de/forschung/devos-worksheet.csv",
      "sha256": "6794db548c6bd8946f5894cbcb5d2293dc29c2794dad6fef912f4bdf03d9bf0d",
      "bytes": 66,
      "contains_result_values": false
    },
    "blank_return_template": {
      "url": "https://kiwerb.de/forschung/devos-return-template.json",
      "sha256": "2d81e199952b43e488ba2c0aadcbcbeb3668108ea7b420741c51e0df7962089e",
      "bytes": 1439,
      "contains_result_values": false
    },
    "worksheet_validator": {
      "url": "https://kiwerb.de/forschung/validate-devos-worksheet.py",
      "sha256": "e588bcc7a5aab9839cbb0ce86cafca1cd9b764ccd4b72d4fcda55432556a6bba",
      "bytes": 3852,
      "contains_result_values": false,
      "network_requests": 0,
      "files_written": 0,
      "license": "No open-source license granted; personal task-use copy only."
    },
    "return_validator": {
      "url": "https://kiwerb.de/forschung/validate-devos-return.py",
      "sha256": "16a8ae16a1001ed6a3a369a89e703831ff25c340c1b2f4f84e796c5096ffdebc",
      "bytes": 7503,
      "contains_result_values": false,
      "network_requests": 0,
      "files_written": 0,
      "license": "No open-source license granted; personal task-use copy only."
    },
    "volunteer_pack": {
      "url": "https://kiwerb.de/forschung/devos-volunteer-pack.zip",
      "sha256": "48dee848febd7aa61b0a164cf888f2f7c61a3985caf45aa42bcbf416316c598a",
      "bytes": 7899,
      "members": 6,
      "contains_result_values": false,
      "contains_third_party_full_text": false,
      "license_scope": "personal participation in this named review task only; no broader license granted"
    }
  },
  "language": "en",
  "canonical_task": {
    "url": "https://kiwerb.de/forschung/devos-independent-review-request.json",
    "sha256": "c9c63d01c677dab8fd3b75359b1ae28fd757ab980e7772046d1722247fcff706",
    "schema_version": "openlab-answer-neutral-review-request-v1",
    "task_slug": "devos-1954-tungsten-curve20-independent-review"
  },
  "translation_scope": {
    "translated_fields": [
      "title",
      "question"
    ],
    "scientific_locator_sources_sequence_return_fields_boundaries_and_artifacts_identical": true,
    "translation_changes_task_identity": false
  }
}